Pull a prank, but don’t get caught
By: SANTOKH SINGH
Publication: The New Paper 15/03/2009
HOW would I have reacted as a father if my sons had been caught streaking on campus?Reading about some male students getting punished for running naked from one building to another at the National University of Singapore set me thinking, and two other reports on youth provided some background.I think I would have sat my boys down and lectured them on respecting themselves, respecting the rights of others to their space (and views) and so on.Then I would have knocked them on their heads for getting caught. (Appeal to Emotion: Use of Humour) (That is something I learnt in the Army – if you pull a prank, make sure you don't get caught.) After which I would have gone to the Hall, and the University, to appeal on their behalf, if it came to that.Too protective? Too relaxed? Excuse for poor upbringing? (Appeal to Emotion: Rhetorical Questions)Perhaps, but the other reports in the same three days would have put some of this in perspective.
First, there was the story of a 17-year-old who was an average student, from an average family, with average grades in school.He was believed to be socially well-adjusted and did not display any signs of violence.But he went on a shooting rampage at his school, killing 10 schoolmates, three teachers and three passers-by before being gunned down by the police.(Appeal to Logic: Factual data and Statistics)That was in Germany on Wednesday.Average studentsThen there was the report of 13 average students, from average schools, and believed to be from average family backgrounds.They, too, were understood to be socially well-adjusted, until they were caught carrying dangerous weapons to school. Their intention, we are told, was to hurt people in their schools.That was in Singapore.So the story of a group of 20-year-olds streaking in their Hall pales in comparison. (To Appeal to Logic: Informed Opinions (Claims backed up by facts)).Yes, they too were all average students, from average families, and with average grades that helped them qualify for university.They are also understood to be socially well-adjusted, active sportsmen who did not display any sign of sexually maladjusted behaviour.Yes, this "group of misfits" went on a streaking rampage, running naked from one hostel block to another in the middle of the night before they were reported to the authorities by some female students.But all they did was to give some students a view they were not comfortable with. They did not kill, or threaten to kill, anyone.
While no one can tell the future, I do live with some confidence that my sons are not likely to turn out killers or likely to take choppers to school. (Appeal to Emotion: Hyperbole (exaggeration)) But I'm not too sure about the streaking, especially if it is done as part of a Hall tradition or an Officer's Mess ragging session in the Army.Yes, I do have some confidence in the value systems of my children, and their ability to tell right from wrong.But I would find it difficult to moralise, let alone punish them with a clear conscience, for something like streaking.After all, I too had gone skinny-dipping with some friends, though not on our shores, when I was in university.It was not to celebrate any sporting victory nor to drown any sorrow. It was also not part of a dare.It was just for the fun of it.And we didn't get caught or thrown out of university. I would rate this commentary a B as the appeals are quite balanced but not balanced enough.
